Skip to main content

Why Cheat India





 A wise man once said that innocence is thought charming because it offers delightful possibilities for exploitation. Why Cheat India, is based on the education system of India, where gullible students and their desperate parents fall into the trap of cheating, to secure a seat in their desired college. An opportunistic Rakesh Singh aka Rocky (Emraan) sweet talks impressionable students and lures them to a world of crime with money. He uses academic achievers to write papers on behalf of other students (the supposedly lesser smart ones) and exploits several other loopholes at the college examination level. He’s the classic anti-hero and his story of crime and corruption highlights a plethora of problems and malpractices that currently plague our education system. Director Soumik Sen’s scathing look at the exam paper mafia and the mind-set of Indian parents often treating their children as ‘investments for the future’ is relevant, but the way he tells this gritty story, doesn’t merit top grade.

The story is based in rural locations like Jaunpur, Kota and Jhansi, where the pressure on the youth to be engineers, doctors and MBA students, is probably far more than what students face in urban cities. As Rakesh Singh’s ambition to be a kingpin of exam mafia unfolds, the viewer gets to witness the kind of nexus that misuses and exploits bright students, and how this is of the biggest scams running in the country. Insights from this world of murky morals and malpractices, has high shock value and that’s what makes the premise of Why Cheat India, quite relevant. But, writer-director Soumik Sen isn’t able to give the narrative the kind of edge and finesse that it deserves. Many scenes from the film feel disjointed, owing to the choppy editing and inconsistent screenplay. Certain situations in the film, like Sattu’s blind trust on Rakesh, despite being aware that he’s just another spoke in Rocky’s business wheel, doesn’t make any sense. Rocky’s personal story, doesn’t add much depth to the plot. The second half throws up some surprises and twists, heightening the drama in the plot. 

What does pass with distinction is Emraan Hashmi’s performance as the wily and confident, Rakesh. The actor pulls it off in every frame with assurance and ease. Even though most of his lines are like a series of punches clamouring for claps, Emraan’s charm and intensity keeps you hooked. The fresh faces of Shreya Dhanwantary and Snigdhadeep Chatterjee are perfectly cast in the roles of naïve characters.

The story and concept of Why Cheat India holds a lot of merit, and if the execution was the sharper and steadier, this one had the potential to graduate to another level. Even with the flaws in the story, the film and its various subjects have enough at hand to keep you entertained.




वाय चीट इंड‍िया में हमारे एजुकेशन स‍िस्‍टम का वो मुद्दा उठाया गया है ज‍िस पर हम अक्‍सर ही खबरें पढ़ते रहते हैं। कहानी के केन्‍द्र में है रॉकी भैया यानी राकेश सिंह (इमरान हाशमी)। वह इंटेलीजेंट बच्‍चों को पैसे द‍िलाकर अमीर बच्‍चों की जगह एंट्रेंस टेस्‍ट में बिठवाता है। इस तरह उसने अपना एक एंपायर खड़ा कर द‍िया है। लेकिन उसकी जिंदगी तब बदल जाती है, जब उसका सामना एक इंटेलीजेंट मिडल क्‍लास स्‍टूडेंट सत्‍येंद्र दुबे यानी सत्‍तू और उसके पर‍िवार से होता है। 
फ‍िल्‍म की एक खूबी ये है क‍ि इमरान हाशमी के क‍िरदार को कहीं से भी ये द‍िखाने की कोश‍िश नहीं की गई है क‍ि वो सही है या गरीबों की मदद कर रहा है। अगर वो गलत है तो उसे उसी तरीके से पर्दे पर उतारा गया है। कई जगह ऐसा भी हुआ क‍ि उसका प्‍लान फेल हो जाता था और वो पकड़ा भी जाता था। ऐसे में किरदार को असल जिंदगी जैसा ही रखा गया है। उसे ग्‍लैमराइज्‍ड करने का प्रयास नहीं किया गया। 
फ‍िल्‍म का पहला ह‍िस्‍सा खास प्रभावित करता है। वैसे भी एजुकेशन स‍िस्‍टम में हो रहे घोटालों पर बनने वाली ये पहली फ‍िल्‍म है और जिस तरीके से घटनाएं द‍िखाई गई हैं, उससे हम सभी खुद को जोड़ कर देख सकते हैं और कई चीजें हमारी आंखें भी खोलती हैं। कहानी को मेकर्स ने द‍िलचस्‍प अंदाज में पिरोया है। लेकिन सेकंड हाफ में फ‍िल्‍म की रफ्तार थोड़ी फीकी हो जाती है। वहीं एजुकेशन सिस्‍टम की कहानी में रोमांस को फुटेज देना भी थोड़ा खलता है। हालांकि थोड़ी देर में कहानी फ‍िर ट्रैक पर आ जाती है। 

वैसे कहानी में एंटरटेनमेंट की थोड़ी कमी है और यही इस फ‍िल्‍म में एक कमी नजर आती है। हालांक‍ि दूसरी फ‍िल्‍म के लिहाज से डायरेक्‍टर सौमिक सेन का न‍िर्देशन बढ़‍िया है और फ‍िल्‍म देखने के बाद इस बात की तारीफ सभी करेंगे क‍ि ये हीरो को महान बनाने की कहानी नहीं बल्‍क‍ि मजबूत कंटेंट और अच्‍छे सब्‍जेक्‍ट वाली फ‍िल्‍म है। 
वाय चीट इंड‍िया में इमरान हाशमी ने अपने करियर की बेस्‍ट परफॉर्मेंस दी है। सत्‍तू का रोल भी एक्‍टर ने बखूबी न‍िभाया है तो श्रेया धनवंतर‍ि ने डेब्‍यू फ‍िल्‍म के साथ दिखा द‍िया है क‍ि वह अच्‍छा काम पाने की हकदार हैं। फ‍िल्‍म में डायलॉग्‍स शानदार हैं तो स‍िनेमैटोग्राफी पर भी मेहनत की गई है। बैकग्राउंड म्‍यूज‍िक भी फ‍िल्‍म में द‍िलचस्‍पी दिखाता है लेकिन इसकी एड‍िट‍िंग अगर कसाव ल‍िए होती तो फ‍िल्‍म और शानदार बन सकती थी। 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Maaran

Even as early as about five minutes into Maaran, it’s hard to care. The craft seems to belong in a bad TV serial, and the dialogues and performances don't help either. During these opening minutes, you get journalist Sathyamoorthy (Ramki) rambling on about publishing the ‘truth’, while it gets established that his wife is pregnant and ready to deliver ANY SECOND. A pregnant wife on the cusp of delivery in our 'commercial' cinema means that the bad men with sickles are in the vicinity and ready to pounce. Sometimes, it almost feels like they wait around for women to get pregnant, so they can strike. When the expected happens—as it does throughout this cliché-ridden film—you feel no shock. The real shock is when you realise that the director credits belong to the filmmaker who gave us Dhuruvangal Pathinaaru, that the film stars Dhanush, from whom we have come to expect better, much better. Director: Karthick Naren Cast: Dhanush, Malavika Mohanan, Ameer, Samuthirakani Stre...

Kuthiraivaal

  Kuthiraivaal Movie Review:  Manoj Leonel Jahson and Shyam Sunder’s directorial debut Kuthiraivaal brims with colours and striking imagery. This is apparent as early as its first scene, where its protagonist Saravanan alias Freud squirms in his bed, suspecting a bad omen. As some light fills his aesthetic apartment wrapped with vintage wall colours, his discomfort finally makes sense—for he has woken up with a horse’s tail! The scene is set up incredibly, leaving us excited for what is to come. But is the film as magical as the spectacle it presents on screen? Kuthiraivaal revolves around Saravanan (played by a brilliant Kalaiyarasan) and his quest to find out why he suddenly wakes up with a horse’s tail, and on the way, his existence in life. Saravanan’s universe is filled with colourful characters, almost magical yet just real enough—be it his whimsical neighbour Babu (Chetan), who speaks about his love for his dog and loneliness in the same breath, or the corner-side cigar...

Valimai

  H Vinoth's Valimai begins with a series of chain-snatching incidents and smuggling committed by masked men on bikes in Chennai. The public is up in arms against the police force, who are clueless. In an internal monologue, the police chief (Selva) wishes for a super cop to prevent such crimes. The action then cuts to Madurai, where a temple procession is underway.then we are introduced to ACP Arjun (Ajith Kumar), the film’s protagonist, whose introduction is intercut with scenes from the procession. Like a God who is held up high, we see this character rising up from the depths. In short, a whistle-worthy hero-introduction scene. We expect that Vinoth has done away with the mandatory fan service given his star's stature and will get around to making the film he wanted to make. And it does seem so for a while when Arjun gets posted to Chennai and starts investigating a suicide case that seems connected to the chain-snatching and drug-smuggling cases from before. Like in his pr...